It's just after this screen! I don't get an error pop up, just rerouted to the main menu. I'm using MacOS Monterey. I'll try clearing the data and reinstalling!
Looks like that fixed it! Thank you so much! Looking forward to discovering all the mushrooms! I'm so in love with this game, I'm even making my own guide to make sure I find ALL the mushroom babies :') so excited for whatever comes next!!!