Hey Dev, i think i has found a way to fix it (soft of) by turn on a random replay and turn the game off (close it or AltF4) then open the game back. Next you just need to open a random replay and that it. (it work on Laptop but Pc? idk)
Yeah, replays have some weird state situation going on - they remember whether you had the LAST replay paused or not, too, which is pretty cumbersome (ideally they'd all start paused)