I see that main menu screen and the background of it with all the different character hands, and that got me thinking. You should add an ability to change your cursor in the game, so instead of the pointy finger that was in Baldi's Basics forever now, you can switch to Principal's finger, Bully's nub, or The Test's glove.
That way there's more customization for player don't really care for the normal cursor and change it from time-to-time, and maybe you can get these cursors by doing little side quests to unlock the others.
Like if you want to get Bully's little nub/fist, you have him get sent to detention 5 times, or to unlock The Test's glove, you have to experience the "blinding" effect and survive it 3 or 5 times.
Just a little idea I had. :)