Im just curious, because i did this and was only able to forge the Companion/comrade blade.
Are their 3 variations using the same materials or can you forge all 3 in 1 playthrough (because the Talon/fang and Spellblade/spellsword are locked out at the castle still, and i only got the option in the sand village for the one i completed).
Im gonna check again but im sure i chrcked him a couple times now since forging the companion blade.