I don’t understand how to fish. The example has 3d6, 2,4,4 “landing on a picture of two catfish”, based on the included diagram im not sure what that means. Either way assuming all three dice landed on catfish, in this example why was the difficulty set to 8 to catch them?
if one player fishes and misses all the fish with their die or dice, are they free to fish again immediately? Is there a limit, or drawback, to fishing repeatedly at a fishing location?
I played this recently and had the same issue. Ran it by the table and no one understood it. I ended up just making up rules that gave the players a bunch of fish so that they had a bunch of pips to spend on new stuff, since none of them seemed to enjoy the idea of fishing repeatedly for pips anyway.
I had them roll a d6 to determine the type of fish they found in a 'school' of fish (treating it as a d3) then 3d6 to dermine the amount of fish. Then I set a rating they had to beat based on how hard the amount and size of fish sounded. Then if they failed the next roll I let another person on the boat try to help them pull it in.
Players didn't seem to hate it. But did not seem to like that they rolled so much to fish. Again I think fishing was their least favorite part of the fishing adventure. They mich preferred mapping the river basin and uncovering all the secrets in it.
Hi! Hope you're doing great! Thanks so much for the comment and sorry for the slow response!
Catfish is the big one, as described on page 16. I feel maybe we should have added the names of the species in the diagram for clarity, your confusion makes total sense.
Since Fishing counts as an Action, it is up to the GM to determine difficulty like any other. It's a super rules light game, so the GM could simply define the Difficulty for a Fishing Action according to the fiction they're envisioning. Fishing near a waterfall could be way harder than fishing in a calm lake, for example. (page 9, The Catch Roll)
And, finally, the only hard limit on fishing is the equipment's HP, representing wear and tear to the fishing gear, although miss on the die drop table does not count as a failure. You need to hook up fish and fail the Action roll in order to damage the equipment. That's as far as limits go, rules as written, but of course you could always make rulings of your own in order to limit fishing activities
I hope this answers your questions! Feel free to get in contact if you need anything!
Cheers!
