This game is so good! I just finished all the routes and I loved each one. I fell in love with all the characters (except Obadiah. He scared the sh*t out of me).
The overall story would make a great anime. It's long and in-depth but moves along quickly enough that I didn't get bored. I have to say it was more wholesome, hilarious, and heartwarming than I thought it would be. The rating doesn't really need to be 18+ except (maybe) for the mushroom part.
I think what I loved most about this game is how funny some of the options are. Playing John's route I had so many negative relationship points because I wouldn't stop acting like a brat with him. I guess he loved it though because he still dated me (even after I got him tortured for not bowing??). He's definitely not as picky as Danny (I had to restart Danny's route because I didn't have enough relationship points ~I'm mean~). I could tell you put a lot of time and effort into making amusing choices that mattered and I appreciate that.
The visuals of the game were good. The bgm was gorgeous and made me happy to wake up each day in the game. I was happy about this because the game is so long it would have been sad if it had annoying music.
John's route was my favorite because of how many options there were and how cute his dating scene and escape scene (and post-torture scene) were. Also, getting texts from Marcus was funny. Coda's was a really sweet route too. I think his route was most interesting as far as storyline goes and it's connection with Theo and Justice. Danny is just overall sweet and cute and loveable (I love Icky the slightly damaged kitty!). Aaron's route was kind of funny. It didn't have as much content and the content it did have was strange but enjoyable. Aaron himself is adorable. I would recommend playing Coda's route first --> John's --> Aaron's --> Danny's. The endings make the most sense in that order but any order works out okay.
I kind of wanted a Marcus or Justice route to see what dating them would be like. Would Marcus still constantly try to kill me if I was his girlfriend?
Amazing game! Great job!