I was one of the people who was lambasting the game because I thought I got burned on the Kickstarter. And now I feel I'm one of the game's biggest fans because it's honestly very good.
Maybe it was just that my expectations were so low, but there is a ton to this game. It's longer than I thought it'd be, lots of variety between the many routes, and treads some unexpected ground in terms of LGBTQ+ issues. It's not too deep, but it does feel like Coming Out On Top with respect to the heart that shines through in the game's writing. You can tell that the creator loved what they were doing in spite of the pain it was clearly causing them.
The inconsistency of the art holds it back somewhat, and I'm still figuring out how I feel about its structure, but overall I think AMAP is fantastic!