I really liked this one. The puzzles were reasonable and felt grounded in the setting. The characterization was great as well, the art was great (love the flashlight effect), and the ending was strong.
I think I may have gotten softlocked during my first playthrough, by taking the cup as Scotty before he went away? At least, I *assumed* I was softlocked, after wandering around without making any progress for a while, so I started a new game and didn't take the cup this time. But then I saw that Scotty comes back eventually, so maybe I wasn't softlocked during the first game (I'm not sure what triggers Scotty coming back, so maybe I technically didn't need the cup yet at the time?). In any case, aside from that I was able to finish the game without issues.
Overall, this was very solid, polished, and fun entry!