Hey! The rule for the one item only was implemented so people don't overwork themselves. We're inclined to say no to this, especially if the item would be a separate drawing from the one in the BG. I'd want more clarification about this, because if it'd be the case of having the 3 items floating in the BG and then one of them disappearing from the BG and appearing on the character, that'd be an absolute "not allowed".
Viewing post in !READ THIS! Rules, Interpretations, & FAQ
That was the initial idea, but now that I know it's not allowed, what if the extra items don't appear in the BG, but only as player input text (or player choice as part of the story text - haven't decided)? When the player inputs/chooses the right item, then the one item appears on the sprite. Is that allowed?