This game would be so much better if you weren't forced plot wise to 'romance' only Emily. Sure you can fool around with multiple but having only one true love interest and being forced to truly only love or care about just Emily is dumb as hell and irritating.
Along with the fact with how childish and stupid the MC is made to act. He acts like a 10 year old in most situations and just an outright pussy. If there was some better character growth, more love interests (just an Ashley ending would make it great), like the main girls/interests and maybe minor endings or smaller routes with the other girls. I feel there's a lot of potential in a route for Piper with how you set that one up or even the doctor.