I have been wondering something similar but my main question is if there is a 2nd option to dealing with the ghost ship besides of the "give up" option during the fight. personally I don't like the idea of giving our elven friend to a ghost it was bad enough we couldn't choice the outcome with Nel to let her or keep her hands off us but that mostly effects the MC. story wise i understand with Nel but yeah i am really wondering if there is another option with the ghost ship or if one could be added in future updates