Thanks so much! Designer/artist here, it really means a lot to read such a nice review (especially because this was my first game jam!). We had such a blast making this, and had a LOT of fun designing and playtesting the puzzles :)
I'm glad you mentioned the music, we were so happy with what the guys made -- yes, it was written, performed and recorded the old fashioned way (albeit with an electronic keyboard, because the church we asked wouldn't let us use their real organ!) We would have loved to record more tracks but like so many things we just didn't have the time.
I completely agree with the feedback about cutscenes and connection to the character / story. We'll hopefully end up doing an expanded version of the game, with more levels, mechanics, cutscenes, and music, so I hope you come back for more in the future! Out of curiosity -- can you remember which puzzle was the mix of humour and cruelty?