I really like the art, animation, and music. Although, it's not clear which fish to catch - good job otherwise.
Viewing post in The Only Man and the Sea jam comments
We think that realising of what is the correct fish is part of the game, and tried to make it more or less evident. However, you are not the first player to point that out, so we may rework it after the voting. The most important hint is the music, that changes when just before the fish is going to appear. Also the marlin size and effects are different :D
Thank you very much for you feedback!