10 out of 5 for presentation. The art is absolutely gorgeous. Music and SFX work well.
The gameplay is pretty fun, but the difficulty does not seem to escalate. If I'm not mistaken, the crafting recipes are as complex as they're going to get right at the beginning of the game. Some progression would have been good.
Also--this is silly, but it took me forever to figure out that I just needed to wave my cursor (without clicking) in order to shape the weapons. That would have been a helpful thing to note in the instructions.