This was a blast to play! I love it!
Sadly, I don't think it's all that original considering the number of cooking type games that already exist in the world, and while it does technically adhere to the theme, the limitation of one object at a time didn't feel like a limitation and more just a standard trope of such cooking style games. So I couldn't give it too high a rating in either of those categories.
But that doesn't mean it's a bad game! Just that it doesn't really meet the creative goal of the jam or its theme.
In the design category, if I could give it a 10/5, I definitely would! Well done, and I love the insane level of polish you all put into this! (Might want to actually turn this into a full and paid game at some point, it's that good).