I'm not a huge fan of conceptual takes on jam themes (though I've done it before myself lol) — I was always going to be more excited by an interesting mechanical one — but that's probably all I could drum up for criticism here if I were really trying.
This submission feels so cohesive and complete. It's cute as a button, and the QoL features included are so appreciated. I was super impressed when I got caught the first time and only had to continue from my most recently satisfied NPC.
Getting to choose your character and having the treats change to match is one of those above-and-beyond things that really wins me over, especially considering the time constraints of a jam.
Good luck with the judging!