You can get both, but you can't get both in the same run. You have to do Nightlight and Moose's quest twice but change up one thing while doing the quest.
what do you change? because I tried not accepting being nightlites mate then telling moos and going on with that but didnt get the acheivment, then I killed nightlight but that didnt do anything. (Im going for the Cheater cheater Flower Eater, i know how to get the other one)
It depends on how you reply to Nightlight when she asks you if you think that there's anything wrong with having multiple mates when she's trying to be poly. Simply changing your answer to no when replying to her gets you the Cheater Cheat Flower Eater achievement.
