Do you have a general idea for the plot to the next game? If you're looking for ideas, I'd suggest a zombie apocalypse themed one. Sure it's probably been done to death (no pun intended), but I love a good zombie story. Maybe some character routes are lost not by making the wrong choices with them specifically, but rather the decision that your group chooses could affect a character's fate, for example, taking a risk for supplies ends up getting a character killed. Just some food for thought. I'm sure whatever you end up doing is going to be great, just like Once in a Lifetime and this game