Hmm this is a tricky case. I don't think I would personally consider Dylan a member of the Lisp family, though it descends from it. Is Dylan's syntax homoiconic like Lisp s-expression syntax? I don't want to be too strict about what qualifies as a Lisp, though. Without turning this into a debate, does anyone else have thoughts here? I'd be inclined to say "sure, go for it" as long as it doesn't open the door for things like "JavaScript should be allowed because it's inspired by Scheme." Dylan feels obscure enough to be permissible, possibly.