So, as it's coded, there are three conditions in order to invite Lucille to the party. They are: you've discovered Lucille's interest in anime, you've established with Peach that you're going to start inviting people and there's an active time limit before the day of the party, and it's evening when you talk to Lucille (That's when she's most willing to talk about anything besides anime.) As for asking Marline about Susie and Susanne; the way it's coded... hmm, yep, that's not right. The way it's coded: if you DON'T ask Susie and Susanne about their milk production before playing the game with them, the option to talk with Marline about them WON'T come up. You could however win against them to clear the condition of there being a challenge, then ask them about their production. The story will look very confusing from there though. If you do this, the option to talk with Marline should come up.