Gosh, Really cool game and concept, and a creative idea. here is my feedback:
-The SFX and Music are very decent and suitable so really great job on this part
-I really liked the cursor being a cat paw
-I’d recommend indicating in the paper or in any other way that if a player mistakenly took an ingredient, they should press on the cauldron because it may not be clear for everyone
-For some reason the text of the help display over each other which make it a bit hard to read, so try to look into it. check the image attached to see what i mean.
-It was also a great idea to indicate a mistake by a player through the candles (Side note: I noticed that you didn’t make a lose screen and the player can win after losing all lives but this seems intended but it is not that of any issue anyway)
Overall, it is a very great and solid submission, so great job and Keep it up!