Late but still
happy birthday Amicus!
I get what you mean, like i said everyone has their own interpretation of something, but there truly are times when what someone says is just plain wrong
The examples i used:
Jelloapocalypse's video about Adventure Time is horrible because he really gets the show wrong, saying stuff like "the arcs go nowhere and the characters don't grow as people"(said "arcs" are either from one off episodes about the side characters to show they have lives too and are not about introducing any new major side characters, or arcs that don't have conclusions yet because the show was literally still ongoing when the video was made), some of his critisims are understandable(like what he said about Breezy) but the thing is: a lot of them stop being valid after season 2, and sometimes he says stuff that makes it look like he either didn't watch the entire show and just read a summary of the rest online or didn't pay attention to it, like criticising that the Lich was imprisoned in amber for 5 seasons when in reality it was only for 2, he's disingenuous and unusually mean spirited during the video, for some reason he thought it was a good idea to say that the entire crew of the show are brainless idiots(except Rebecca Sugar, for some reason he puts her as the only good one).
And Lily Orchard's video about Pokémon is worse, she refuses to engage with anything, mashes the "A" button trough the dialogue and it seems like she just wants to get to the end as fast as possible, her critisisms are bs, she complains about having to read, that the games try to tell a story and that the games are challenging(and why wouldn't they be, she hacks the games from gen 3 onwards to switch the starter for a Ralts and Ralts has weaker stats than the starters) and her takes on gen 5 are the worse, she loathes N just because he makes her read, mischaracterizes him and even sides with Ghetsis(N's abuser) at one point.
I don't think i need to say why that take on The Owl House is bad.
(Anyway, i don't care about this disscusion anymore, im tired and i didn't saw the notif to your reply unltil today)
I just pointed out the TOH take cuz im saying that just like that person got the show wrong you got the vn Wrong
Just because you didn't understood it doesn't automatically make it "satire"
But i guess everyone has their own interpretation of something even if they got it wrong, like for example that bs take on TOH, Jelloapocalypse horrible video about Adventure Time and Lily Orchard's also horrible retrospective on Pokémon(those are what your take reminded me of)
But you seem determined on your view and internet "arguments" are exhausting so im going to stop and leave, and i'll leave this meme that i found on tumblr.
Also-
SPOILERS
there's the Meera ending(wich Khemia implies that it's the canon one) where Marco forces the parents to tell him the entire plan so when he goes back to earth he has the parents at his mercy, he knows tasks he'll have to do and can choose wether or not he wants to do them in advance and force the parents to come up with another way.
Im very passionate(and autistic) about this vn so i don't like when someone misinterprets it to this deegre, even saying the vn is "satire"
ngl, your takes on Adastra kind of reminded me of a The Owl House take i saw where someone says that Luz is a spoiled brat that made Amity's and Hunter's lives worse by "distracting them from success"(she took Hunter away from his abuser and made Amity stand up to her abusive mom)
So, basically they got everything wrong.