I think #2 is the most accurate and 'best' for cataloging as it eliminates the risk of having name collisions.
However #3 would be the most useful for me, as nearly everything I seed uses the DVD ID.
I could see #1 being useful too, if someone has a particular way of naming things or if they seed a lot of things where the filenames aren't the best for cataloging.
Is it feasible to have a commandline option to choose how to rename the folders? I think it makes sense that the default would be #2, since that's the most accurate and the safest option. But I'd love to be able to use #3 too.
Jav-It catalog "C:\" -nameformat ___
- p: Proper ID ie: ASDF00123 (new default)
- d: DVD ID ie: ASDF-123
- f: Filename ie: use the existing filename as the foldername
- t: Title ie: Use the Proper Title as the foldername (current)