itch.io

It was directly during the intro of 2. It was in red text as if it was a decision you'd picked previously. (if that helps)
(during the parts where old people start to come by)
Decisions I remember making (As sometimes they matter?):
No futa

all the way with Avi

Let him see breasts
Make him stop

First: I want to say I'm enjoying these stories you did great

But second, as the OP said continuity: In the first game was there ever even an option to NOT tell Your BFF TOM about the succubus and the contract? Because in the second one it automatically treats it as if he never knew.

I specifically remember scenes of Tom warning you about becoming addicted to sex because of the contract in game 1.