The Cross Media bar is great with keyboard, but pretty broken using a gamepad (it goes so fast instead of making you flick the stick and it seems to move the stack to the left of the cursor?)
I really didn’t like which item was selected in the spiral menu. My brain wanted it to be like 45 degrees farther along.
grid with tabs is very simple and worked well. It might be the one that best keeps the original intent while improving the speed of selection.