WhaleHusband, I wanted to let you now that I liked your game!
The 'salad-fingers' vibe is creepy and I liked it. The overall game was a bit more vulgar/gory than I normally like. (I didn't watch the Saw movies). However, I love the multiple endings. The voice acting for still frames plus Gwen Sleeveless was nice. The controls, sound effects and models were all very good. I especially was impressed with the end of the Waltz. That bit where you must spin in a circle. I make simple games in Unity for my kids and I was like, "Oh what a bit of code this must have taken to get right". Also, I like the overall narrative, its not simply join a cult, there is motive and then there are consequences. It reminds me of 'The Seventh Gate' in that way.
I like 'walking simulators' and BD has enough stuff to engage with, that it is compelling. It only takes about an hour to get all the endings, and I like that. I like to sit down and spend an evening in a story, much like watching a movie. Plus when you offer it for $4 I don't mind taking a chance, if its garbage I won't feel like I've wasted my money. Though, I don't feel that way :).
So, keep it up, do more, make more games like this!