I can't seem to recruit her, I just get the two normal scenes that repeat for each path. Am i missing something?

A battle victory is required.

Upon victory you will get the options for her to banish herself, or to ask her to join you (if your Charisma is high enough).
Upon defeat you will have your three choices as standard.

Hiii,

I'm using an illusionist that I named "Doug"...I'm not sure how-or if-i can get another follower yet One Vanilla