I'd like to preface this review by pointing out that this is not a game - it's an anti-game. But by Jove, this could make even Captain Ahab let out a good ol' hearty chuckle! The anti-game humour is on point throughout, it's fantastic.
The presentation is almost immaculate, and does contribute to the anti-game philosophy. Opening every chest does feel very satisfying. The fish seems to have a new line of dialogue for every in-game interaction, and he's voiced pretty decently at that.
Extraordinarily creative, great job!