Thank you very much for your detailed review. In matter of fact many topics you mentioned are being discussed in our team regularly.
We started with simple idea of writing down list of 30 fetishes and then we assigned them to each girl and build the story around it. At the moment we are still in phase of showing individual girl personalities but soon as more locations are filled in the real deal starts - relationships (we wanted each girl have hobbies / friends & enemies and we have a plan to include MC doing favors for them, where choices will lead to multiple meetups to their friends or foes (to create struggle which make logical sense thx to collision of different personalities) and rewards - eg. knowing someone better / deciding to help the girl with her life struggle).
The thing that inspired us are shows like how I met your mother / American pies / friends / first 30 mins of not just another teenage movie where you are put in a world of opportunities. Like when you played skyrim for the first time and you couldn't decide where to go first. At the moment we do realize we are not there yet. Just started going in that direction. Look at the increasing pace we are improving: https://imgbox.com/GmAY6Dkx and we believe if we don't give up we could tell a big story. For example Jess - most likable character have the best character story planned, yet zero of it is in the game currently. Threesome with Victoria and Cameron to proove who doesit better by daring MC? Why not! Foursome with Jess / Katy / Judy? And we are not stopping there.
You scratched the surface and our endgame lies in animations with multiple girl characters, swaps, public use, roleplay to the extreme - Eg. Victoria will do anything to keep title of school president by providing blowjobs before election at the toilets... she will think many students are coming there but it will be MC ... like 5 times... imagine the shock when you will meet Charlie coming out from toilet or even Richard like 5 times each and she saying stuff like ''I think I have space for one more vote in my stomach thinking she did 20 guys but in matter of fact it will be ''Nerds team'' going there and pretending they were different boys. And NTR... well I am old school creator, who want to drive the spark of imagination by writing strong ideas and let them compete which one feels the best, no matter if they are my ideas or summited by someone - I believe this is the strength every game could use and boi we just scratched the surface. We are even considering adding some options early on that will for example give options to skip all NTR scenes (now that we have many scenes even this creative option could make sense - we definitely don't want force anyone to see scenes that hit you like a hammer in the face, but let Player decide)
So there are plenty of opportunities, and to achieve them in reasonable delivery time we would need 1-2 more people in our team, sadly because of Patreon ban we are still on the edge of survival working on the game. But we are not giving up and that's why fans like you matter and we will be always willing to discuss ideas with cool people like you who understand the insane amount of work behind our efforts - 2D VN adult games are time costly AF!