Lovely graphics, very charming atmosphere and sound design. The game loop was really relaxing and fun! I played for a few minutes and had a great time :)
My only issue I encountered was that the recipes were sensitive to the order of ingredients, which felt a bit counterintuitive. There were times I wanted to do it out of order because of where the herbs spawned next to the cat, but that ended up not completing the potion.
I think it could be cool for certain recipes to have a special order though... like "add these 3 herbs (any order), then add a drop of dragon's blood (at the end)", like a catalyst that activates the magic.
Really great start to the game! I had the music playing while typing this review and it was a great choice for music! Also loved the little added details like the firefly and using the feather sprite as the cursor. Well done!!