gotcha, thanks for clearing that up, I figured out some of that already, but I wasn't sure cause I gave something that said it was green to Willow once, since I thought one of her things was anything green, but she didn't like it
It was probably included something she didn't like. If the gift item includes anything they hate, that would take priority. Like for Lilith, she hates anything athletic so even if it's black or purple, she'll not like it.