Did you get the conversation with Sayra before the one with Gisette?
Yeah, you have to get Sayra’s approval higher to be able to get the peace or rebel outcomes.
Quote from Aly earlier in this thread:
“Sayra's friendship and respect are boosted by choosing katyia's legacy, being nice to the servants (introducing yourself, comforting ria, sticking up for sayra when the delegate is bugging her, ) inviting her the onvu tournament, or the girls night, saving Imogen at the trial (this is a big one, it gives a 20/20 boost for the best performance and a 10/10 for saving her)”