you're having the exact issue I had a couple weeks ago. Everything that was already said
But you also might need Rebel approval. After the last rebel secret, Mrs. White in the servants quarters, if Clarmont's rivalry goes to 50% then rebel approval isn't high enough.
Did you get Mrs. White's Gift and Sayra/Ria's gift before the breakfast?
And on day 1, did you talk to Gisette at all? if so what was the last answer you gave?