I’m 100% in agreement with you
I’ve been trying to leave very specific feedback of what they did well, what they can improve…
but i’m also keeping in mind if I see it’s probably someone’s first game I’m not gonna tell you “well this is a basic crappy platformer” even if objectively you might say that. I try to see where people are in their journey and give feedback that matches what I think is reasonable to expect from them if that makes sense