Skip to main content

On Sale: GamesAssetsToolsTabletopComics
Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

WE NEED TO STOP!

A topic by ViolettMel created Jul 30, 2024 Views: 257 Replies: 7
Viewing posts 1 to 6
(+7)

I am seeing this unhealthy behavior of going to the others games and rating them just for them to rate YOUR game. Game jam is like sport, you need to be honest. We all love what we do, and we all want to be rated, I understand. But man,  just look at our most rated submissions! There are much more interesting and enjoyable games out there!

I do not wish to devalue anyones work, I am honored to work along so much interested people who truly love what they do.  People who are now on the top did put a lot of work,  but it is just cynical. 

Here is what I wanted you to look into: go on, try different games, and SAY THE TRUTH. Did you like it? Cool! Did you not? Write suggestions on how to improve it!


I take this opinion fully on me, and I DO NOT represent the opinion of my team. We are all people after all. Thank you for your time reading this. 

Please be aware that this is new to me, and if you have something to say on this topic, or if you think this is normal for game jams on your experience, I would love to discuss it

Submitted(+3)

I’m 100% in agreement with you

I’ve been trying to leave very specific feedback of what they did well, what they can improve…

but i’m also keeping in mind if I see it’s probably someone’s first game I’m not gonna tell you “well this is a basic crappy platformer” even if objectively you might say that. I try to see where people are in their journey and give feedback that matches what I think is reasonable to expect from them if that makes sense

(2 edits) (+1)

Actually, after my post asking about constructive feedback, there were some people who pointed out our mistakes and gave advice(including you my friends, thank you all for that), and man, that was REALLY helpful!! We already working on it. So, yes, giving feedback based on others experience is very important! It is all about the attitude and  interest to your and others work, not popularity after all.

Submitted(+1)

I believe that people feel like they need to be kind on their reviews and comments.
Nobody here is a professional (well maybe there are a few), so we tend to be more lenient.
Combine this with the fact that people want to get others to play their games, it makes it even harder to be post a negative comment. You never know when the person will be offended and review bomb your game, although i doubt that would ever happen.

(+2)

Yes, after I gave this some thought, I understood that this is actually expected. I probably overreacted a bit heh. I just like being honest you know, and I love hearing actual opinions on my work because I can learn from it, not the “nice game, check in my too” 

Submitted

Well said.

Submitted

I see where you're coming from and I really agree for the most part.

This has only been the 3rd jam I joined but I dont remember this kind of rate spam being that apparent in jams like ludum dare. I would guess that the 'prize' associated with this jam incentivized this kind of behavior.

As for saying the truth in the feedback, I think it depends on what you're rating. I think a lot of submissions here are from relatively new developers, and sometimes what they need is motivation, not brutal honesty. In most cases, the problems with their games are readily apparent things that they don't need to hear commented over and over anyway.

As for the "cool game, rate mine too" feedback, yeah im not really a huge fan of that behavior (i still rate their game tho cuz i feel bad)