I think aesthetically this game does hit the creepy vibe, and with polish it can be quite a fun game!
A few issues I ran into is the audio looping constantly including what I think was the ending in which the voice tells us we are bleeding even while still alive, as well as my character seemed to have locked and was unable to look around which made picking cards very hard.
I like the idea of mix elements to protect yourself on the theater screen, it is a very interesting way of doing the idea of alchemy.
For your first game ever this was Extremely impressive!
Cheers, hope to see you next Game Jam.