I tried my best but I didn´t figure out everything. Had the apples and the... chocolate(?) and I had the mushroom in my hand but goddamn I didn´t figure out how to get the mushroom and me to the mixer... At least the cat had a tast of "person and mushroom". Hope it was delicious. The game was still fun enough to play several times :D Plus the idea behind it was really, really cool!
That's cool, you made a great job. Puzzles are a bit tricky because there will always be players who struggle and there will always be players who think it's too easy. Making good puzzles that keep the player engaged is very hard but I think you made a great job!
A good way to guide people who are overwhelmed with the puzzle is to make hints available but only for the players who need it. That's what I heard and it seems like a good idea. Hope it helps you!