This game is so pretty. I wasn't really sure what to do at first but after running out of time I was able to get an idea of what to look for.
What a twist at the end!
Viewing post in Unintended Consequences comments
I'll try to not spoil it in case other people look at comments but sometimes I had to click on an item multiple times for it to finally register into my inventory. Not sure if it was a bug or a timing thing. I would say you probably did click on the right item, but have to try again because of that issue.