I'm curious between the disagree and bratty option when playing as Brigitte, are they both the same outcome of punishment or different?
I'm mostly choose bratty to get the most negative points on obedience.
They are different. The Bratty Response option will have a stronger effect on her resistance and obedience scores, and she will be punished. With the Resist option, the effect on obedience and/or resistance will be less (though still different then the Accept option). With Resist, she will eventually give in after being punished. It's meant to be a middle ground between Bratty and Accept, for those who like that kind of thing. The punishments themselves are a little bit different. She will be set on either a Bratty or Sub storyline after Chapter 3 Act 4 depending on total points at that stage.