Mmm when you try to pay, doesn't Itch.io offer you more options? You should be able to pay with your credit card at least.
It only provides the Pay Pal button. I do have other ways of paying on Itch. That includes other cards.
Maybe you can try joining my Patreon for a month? Maybe that way you can pay in a way other than Paypal. And, at the same time, download other games that I have on my Patreon.
I have been thinking about it for a while. But not right now. Maybe in the near future though. What is the cheapest monthly pay for every game?
$5, the same as Yuri Party, and you get both that one and the others I have for sale
