The introduction is top-notch!
I really like the idea of using the flashlight as a weapon to kill enemies (à la Alan Wake)! Love it!!!
The controls are smooth and polished, and the spooky atmosphere you created in the level is fantastic.
Although the level design is great, I found it a bit too big, and I had trouble finding all the toys.
Overall, this is a very impressive first jam entry—congratulations!
Cheers! :D