Last time I tested the skill balance I found Ice to be stronger than both of the other options by quite a bit, so I nerfed it. I'm pretty sure it was still the strongest overall afterwards, because I didn't want to end up making it bad. Do you know how long ago the last time you played was though? I'm pretty sure the last change to skill balance was over a year ago.
Viewing post in Crossdressing in Camelot comments
I have the idea to let the player have another character join their party near the end of the game, so I could potentially add him as an option. I'm not 100% sure if I'll do that yet though, as combat has been designed to just have controllable character until now, so I'll have to see how easy it is to add another one.