I really enjoyed this! I really like Amanda, her design is really cute and I like her character, including her sarcasm and how clever she is. Will keep it vague in case anyone reading hasn't played it, but the whole concept of Mitos Town as a whole is really interesting and good.
The only big negative I had with the game was that the puzzle was kind of frustrating for me. I couldn't figure out how to hide the buttons (space didn't work), so I had some trouble counting for that one hint and telling what one of the numbers was. The idea was really fun, though, I actually had to pull out paper and a pen to solve it, which I enjoyed.
SPOILERS:
I really liked the bait and switch with the puppeteer. I hadn't read any warnings or summaries so everything would be a surprise, so I was really shocked when it went from fun if creepy puppet guy to how terrifying and disgusting Billy was. On the same note, I was happily shocked by how creepy and dark the bad ending with the "new dolly" was. The line about needles and rubbing her eyes made me actually cringe in a good way.
I'd really love to see more set in the same town with the mentioned entities or the puppeteer.I like the girl's line in the bad ending about going around to ask others for ideas. It's a fun implication that all of these horror movie monsters are pleasant to each other and chat about things like torture methods.
I'm excited to see more from you guys! Happy Halloween!