Nice work! I thought you were building an interesting world, and wanted to understand the cult better, but I found the clash of the visuals and the main character referencing modern day things and making jokes kind of took me out of it a bit. It might be cool to take the risk of the main character and the text taking the whole thing more seriously, maybe make it a period piece? You could get some cool creepy vibes going!
Also I liked the eye animation for making choices, that looked really cool.