Thanks for the help... I still can't seem to get the scene despite multiple attempts.
Starting a new game. I avoid choices with Skylar. I always choose the coldest response to her, I never have any fun with her, refuse to use her skateboard, refuse to even give her a hug after she returns from being missing.
No matter how cold I am to her, I never get anywhere with Jessica. (Somehow I always end up at dinner with Skyler at the Fancy restaurant; but I suspect that is to advance the story with Alice.)
I appreciate the help, but I am looking for any more help from anyone on this subject.