The artstyle, lighting and visuals in general are pretty great, and are definitely the highlight of the game for me, being both cutesy while not eliminating the horror. I also think that the atmosphere is generally pretty good, being spooky without being overbearing.
However, i feel like the gameplay could use some touchups. You move very slowly and there isn't much to do except just wander the map randomly and hope you find what the ingredients. It also felt like the pumpkin guy just attacked you randomly without much warning, which led to there not being much counterplay meaning it was just a matter of luck if i was near a haystack or not. If there is a pattern to his attacks i think you should make it easier for the player to pick up on that pattern. I also had some issues with foreground objects blocking my sight, making it hard to see my character.
Overall, a pretty enjoyable experience though.