I love Over the Garden Wall. I think you nicely captured that eerie + old time feel of the show. Sound design was good, the ambient sounds added a lot. Art looked cool; it's unfortunate you didn't get to texture everything though.
I feel either the player should have been a little faster or the environment a little smaller (denser).
Neat, complete, game loop. I had some real anxiety walking all the way back with my load of sticks on my back and my eyes glued to the lantern's timer.
The river was a neat touch, I got lost initially and it helped me find my way back.
Cool submission.
PS. Nice main menu.