I second their suggestion. That would make hunting feel more like hunting and less like...going over and punching a bunch of wild pigs until they give up their meat.
It would also favor using bows and crossbows, as guns would be noisy and alert the rest of the animals around about your presence and go over to fight you, thus making the player try to use a larger variety of weapons regardless of wether they choose to stick with a main weapon they level up a lot for or not.