-----spoilers !!
and rant coming upppppp!!!!!!!!!!!
the scene were rons mom says that "no haha your hallucinating with that dumb doll" (the doll gifted by mr red face?? whos his dad?? who killed him at that time??)
wasnt he technically already dead at that time or was it rons hallucinations again??
and wdym rons mom still sees him in the day but not at night?? its been 19 days since he died, do you mean she keeps on making leftovers for him even though its never empty (assuming that its not rons hallucinations, and the mom doesnt know hes dead yet)?? does she not check up on her kid??
im also confused at the part were she wakes up and checks on the closets first instead of calling out his name because she shouldnt know something bad happened thats related to closets??
i suppose you can chalk it up to that scene where hes scolded by his mom on why hes sitting there, but that wouldnt be a hallucination on rons part, and anything after that was actually her interacting with ron. but like the doll said in the end of the game, hes dead.
...???? but if were gonna assume that was a real interaction, wouldnt rons mom be carrying a corpse?? im just so confused
not only that but apparently rons been dead for 14 days. 14?!?!
after the argument scene the dad had left because he killed ron, which means that rons mom was by herself the entire time. a day without seeing your son in a small house is understandble, somewhat. because your busy working, and probably went straight to bed without checking your sons room.
BUT 14 DAYS?! 14?!?
do you mean she never questions why the house is so quiet? or why ron doesnt seem to greet her whenever she opens the door? does she not think on how her son is gonna eat food? does she even notice her food supplies havent been minus-ed for 14 days?! (regarding the note, it seems that ron alrdy knows how to make food by himself)
oh yeah, the note part too! since the whole experience is after rons death, do you mean that rons mom never questioned why the food was at the table was never eaten? it would... make sense if it was a 'hallucination' but how many more can we justify before it starts sounding like a lazy plot hole fill?!
at the 14th day does she suddenly go "oh shit my son" after completely forgetting he even existed at all?? not only that but why was she suddenly panicked?? ma'am, your son had died for 14 days and you didnt bother to check up on him after a week?!
are you saying that this woman, who loves him so much, just never questioned his absence 😭??
i enjoy the plot, and the interesting concept of a poor boy and his doll but the timelines are so confusing and has never been explained, PROPERLY!!!!!!!!!! i cant tell if its me being dumb and just missing some details but i rewatched the parts on some playthroughs and still couldnt piece a comprehensible story that would explain these questions.....
TLDR;
The plot contains several confusing elements, primarily around the 19-day gap, rons interactions with his mom, and whether hes alive or dead. The lack of consistency in the mom’s behavior (ignoring Ron for so long) and the strange interactions with his ghostly presence create major plot holes that don’t fully explain the story....
(i accidentally mixed up the time on how long ron was dead for lol.. it was 14 days, not 19)