this game can go very fast into morbid curiosity realm and that I think is what can elevate the game (more than jumpscares, but I'm just half immune to jumpscares).
Maybe show statistics on how many players watched until past specific moments? to "judge" who's keeping their humanity
There's something to work on I think
That's a concept that can really go far and be way more unsettling (I know it's just the beginning)